Case study  |  Aviation  |  Market design

How we'd end tarmac waits at O'Hare.

Planes land at one of the busiest airports in the country and then sit on the taxiway because no gate is open. The cause isn't weather or air traffic control. It's the formula that decides who gets the gates.

95%of arrivals at a gate within 5 minutes of landing (target)
4xhow much more a big plane operator can afford to bid for the same gate
40%most gates any one airline can hold
$0new cost to taxpayers. Airlines fund the fix.

The problem

O'Hare's 2018 airline lease gives each carrier gate space in proportion to its share of annual departures. A 50 seat regional jet counts the same as a 180 seat mainline jet. So the cheapest way for an airline to win more gates is to schedule more flights, not move more people.

That's exactly what's happening. United's CEO said publicly the airline would add as many flights as it needed to hold its gate count. Summer 2026 schedules were set to run about 15% above the prior summer, and the FAA had to step in with a cap.

When an airline schedules more arrivals in a bank than it has open gates, the extra planes land and wait. A late departure makes it worse, because the outbound plane is still parked where the inbound one needs to go. Nothing in the current rules charges the airline for that wait. Passengers pay for it in time.

Root cause: the allocation rule rewards flight count. Every incentive in the system points toward more, smaller planes crowding the same gates.

How we approached it

We started the way we start any engagement: find the rule driving the behavior, then change the incentive instead of fighting the symptom. We used AI research tools to pull together and cross check public reporting on the lease terms, the gate dispute between the two hub carriers, and the FAA's intervention. Then we built the economics ourselves, testing what each airline could afford to bid for a gate under different fleet choices.

We set five design goals before writing a single rule: little to no tarmac waiting, the same rules for every carrier, prices set by the market, enough stability for hub airlines to keep investing, and more seats moved through every gate.

The fix: four parts

1. Two tiers of gate auctions

Replace the departure formula with auctions. Terminals 1 and 3 become a hub tier on 10 year leases, with the two terminals offset by five years so only one hub is ever at stake. Terminals 2 and 5 become a flex tier rebid every 2 years, with half the flex gates up each year. Gates are bid individually or in small blocks, so no single auction can wipe out a hub.

The auction is sealed bid, second price: winners pay the bid just below theirs, so airlines bid what a gate is truly worth to them. No carrier can hold more than 40% of all gates. Auction revenue pays down terminal bonds, funds a shared gate pool, and lowers landing fees.

2. Pay to hold, free to resell

Winners pay their lease whether they use the gate or not. An airline can leave a gate empty as breathing room if it wants. Any unused hours can be subleased through an airport run exchange at whatever price two airlines agree on, with every deal posted publicly. If one airline wants another's gate from 1 to 4 pm, it buys the hours instead of lobbying City Hall.

3. Arrival gate guarantee and tarmac fees

This is the part that ends the waiting. Every carrier must show a gate for every scheduled arrival, with a 15 minute buffer. When a plane does wait because the airline's own gate isn't ready, the airline pays by the minute.

Minutes waiting after landingFee per minuteWhere it goes
0 to 5NoneGrace period
6 to 20$100Shared gate pool
21 and up$250Half to the pool, half as credits to passengers on board

FAA ground stops, lightning closures and airport outages are exempt. An airline that crams 12 arrivals into a bank with 10 gates pays for it every day, so the cheaper move is fewer, bigger planes or buying hours on the exchange.

4. A shared gate pool

The airport holds back about 8% of gates and runs them as shared overflow, paid for by tarmac fees and auction revenue. If a plane has waited 5 minutes and a pool gate is free, the operations center sends it there automatically. That covers storms, diversions and mechanical delays no schedule can plan for.

Why the market sorts it out

Two airlines bid on the same narrowbody gate. These figures are illustrative, assuming an 85% load factor and $10 of margin per departing passenger.

Carrier A (mainline)Carrier B (regional)
Daily turns610
Seats per plane17050
Departing seats per day1,020500
Passengers per year316,000155,000
Margin per year$3.2M$1.55M
Expected tarmac fees per year$0$0.73M
Most it can bid per yearAbout $3.2MAbout $0.8M

Under today's rules, Carrier B's 10 departures earn it more gate credit than Carrier A's 6. Under this plan Carrier A wins the gate, moves twice the passengers, and nobody sits on the taxiway.

Who comes out ahead

GroupWhat they gainWhat it costs them
PassengersA gate waiting at landing, shorter taxi times, more competition, credits for long airline caused waitsA few small city regional flights may consolidate onto bigger planes
The airportGates priced at market value, predictable hub revenue for bond ratings, spare capacity funded by airlinesNew staff and systems to run auctions and the exchange
AirlinesA clear price and term for every gate, no flight padding to protect gate counts, a real way in for new entrantsHigher rent at the best gates; carriers above 40% shrink to the cap over time
Nearby residentsThe same passengers on fewer flights, so fewer takeoffs and landings and less idling exhaustBigger jets can be somewhat louder per departure

A better run airport also wins connecting traffic. When arrivals reach a gate on time, airlines can sell shorter connections, and travelers choosing between hubs pick the one where they don't miss them.

The hard parts

ObjectionResponse
Small cities lose serviceReserve a small block of below market gates for essential small market routes.
The richest airline buys every gateThe 40% cap and the shared pool keep capacity no airline controls.
Hub carriers won't investHub terminals lock in for 10 years, and the two hub auctions sit five years apart.
Costs get passed to faresRevenue goes back into lower landing fees and terminal debt, which offsets much of it.
Fees punish airlines for weatherFees apply only when the airline's own gate is the cause.
Airlines will sueLikely. One already sued over the 2025 reallocation. Phasing in with new and expiring gates first lowers that risk.

Rollout

  1. Year 0: Write the rules and start measuring. Publish auction rules, the fee schedule and the exchange design for FAA and DOT review. Log every arrival's landing time, gate in time and the cause of any wait, and publish it by carrier each month. Visibility alone puts pressure on overscheduling.
  2. Year 1: Pilot. Run the first flex auction for Terminal 5, open the exchange, and turn on tarmac fees for all carriers.
  3. Years 2 to 6: Roll in the rest. Terminal 2 joins the flex tier. Terminal 1 goes to its first 10 year auction when its lease allows, and Terminal 3 five years later.
  4. Year 6 on: Steady state. Half the flex gates reprice every year and one hub terminal every five.

How we'd measure success

MetricTarget
Arrivals at a gate within 5 minutes of landing95% or more
Average airline caused wait for a gateUnder 2 minutes
Departing seats per gate per dayUp year over year
Carriers besides the two hubs winning a gate each auctionTwo or more
Auction revenue returned through lower landing fees100%, net of pool costs

What this shows about how we work: we found the one rule driving the behavior, changed the incentive instead of adding enforcement, priced the tradeoffs for every group, and defined success in numbers before anyone spends a dollar. We bring that same approach to your business.

This is an independent proposal. AWBR Innovations has not been engaged by the airport, the city or any airline. Fee amounts, the gate cap and the worked example are illustrative starting points, not figures from any official source.

Sources

Have a problem nobody has solved?

Send it our way. We read every one, and the best ones become our next public write-up.